โฆWelcome to another edition of the Open Book Blog Hop!โฆ
Topic #416
What rules of writing do you break on purpose?
Welcome back to another Open Book Blog Hop! The authors included in this ongoing series wish to thank you for your reads. Even more so, we appreciate that you share our writings with friends. If youโre new to the series, welcome aboard. The authors engage and impress weekly. Prepare to become a regular reader.
It is the purview of any writer to break the rules in writing. That is our legacy. Yet, there are just some conventions we cannot break because the expectations of readers, the industry, and the artform. The delicate dance of rule breaking isn’t careless for the artist who partakes successfully. Their efforts are purposeful and reasoned. Seasoned writers know this better than the novice. That is also understanding learned in studying the works of others with peers and leaders. All necessary lessons for the would be rebel.
That doesn’t really sound like rule breaking. Totally understand that dilemma! Instead, call it a boundary test, or test of the limits writers work in to avoid mucking up the deal between them, the art, and the consumer. That lovely triangle has to maintain their permissions or the transactions collapse.
Have you read Sun Tzu?
The Art of War, or Art of Conflict as others call it, provides advice (sometimes considered rules) usually viewed in the arenas of conflict and war. However, the crux of the work is really about solid leadership. A writer is a leader in the capacity of forming the triangle of agreement between themselves, the art they create, and the audience who will engage with the material. It is our guidance and preparation that designs the successful transaction. When it falls apart, that is on us and our choices, requiring our reflection and redress.
I highly recommend reading this work and viewing it in that context, especially if you’re a writer who wants to extend the boundaries of what is acceptable in writing or just play with them. In fact, any leadership studies will help you get your head on right for the task. After all, what you’re building is community around your works, and as the builder of those works, you’re the authority (leader).
So what rules have I broken? I’m sure I’ve broken more rules than I am aware, but those are just mistakes. If they work, let’s call them happy little accidents. Then, there are choices I have made to blatantly ignore advice and perceived rules. Most of that is within the realm of dialogue. For instance, they tell you not to attempt accents or speech patterns, because you have to maintain consistency and any loss of continuity can ruin the effort. They doubly say not to do this if you’re new. I refused to listen. Continuity and consistency are something I always sort out in edits.
Studying the speech patterns/accents of regional dialects and classes matters a great deal to me. I write historical fiction that addresses social issues. How could I ignore the way that folks talk and still make those characters genuine? If I used proper grammar, they would lose part of who they are. And, this goes for the character who denies their region or class, too. Displaying their speech mannerisms is a powerful tool on screen and in books. What shit advice to tell me not to try!
If I get it wrong, then I fix it. The fixing is the key. Many novice, and even seasoned writers, can be a bit too big for their britches, right? I empathize with them regardless of their britches. This field is tough. Showing vulnerability often translates into inability. The perception of more than capable is a powerful caveat of the art. When readers think you’re not so good at what you do, they’re going to pass over your work for another. Humility goes a long way to losing reader confidence. The market is glutted with manuscripts. Thus, standing out requires confidence and believing in yourself. Weakness is deemed as ill-prepared.
That said, there is a time for humility and there is a time for confidence. When peers tell you something needs fixing, listen up. Go back over the work and test it out. Look, if it doesn’t work, then it’s vindication. On the flip side, if it works you learned something to strengthen you as a writer and that is also vindication. Don’t waste an opportunity to get better at your craft. In time, the sense of who is helpful and who is talking crap becomes quite clear. But, you’ll still mess that up from time to time. That gray area is a tough place to navigate.
They way I see it: don’t mind the typos half as much as minding a rule break that detracts from your work. Beta readers are super helpful in this area. They’re going to tell you if they hate something you did. In the end, it is up to you to incorporate feedback or not. As a leader, having the humility to know you’re not perfect and the attempts made can roll short is key.
For example, the dialogue problem I faced–I chose to ignore the advice of others. What fed into that? Others told me that my dialogue was like watching a film. They heard the characters. I created pictures in their heads. They loved it! You see why that advice didn’t ring true against such feedback. There was a lot of evidence pointing me against the direction. In fact, when tested out, their advice completely ruined the piece and characterizations I meticulously built. It felt flat and pretentious. Who wants to read flat dialogue?
That is just one example of how you’ll know. Taking a run at it and examining the counter points gives a pretty solid support of your stance. While ego can hurt you, knowing your stuff can protect you. It may not be malice with which these advisors work, but their own limited knowledge. Don’t let that bolster your ego, though! Just because you know something doesn’t mean you know it all. You’re still going to have to pull your weight and make every effort to pull off your scheme.
Taking the road of a rebel requires a level of skill born of experience and humility, along with the confidence to accomplish the goal. The process is like putting together a puzzle for the first time, every time. Every piece is different and will call on different skills, while there are those instances that skills and knowledge carry over. As the architect of the book and the leader of this community you forge, there’s a lot to do. Storytelling is far more involved than putting pen to paper. The majority of what we create is not planned, but the mechanics are, whether we admit this or not.
Do I think a novice should test the boundaries of writing rules? Absolutely, I do. This is where you find your unique voice. Couch this, however, in the fact that you know you’re beginning. This is not the space in which you act seasoned and above criticism. I am not sure there is ever a space for that, regardless of your skill level. If you go forth knowing that every misstep is a lesson and skill building opportunity, you’ll do great. If you instead view that as questioning your authority and diminishing you, you’re going to struggle. We writers will find ourselves in both spots in our careers.
Test those boundaries. We are artists. If it works that is amazing and well done! If it doesn’t, examine the reasons why and try again if it makes sense to do so. Also, well done! This is a marathon, not a sprint.
Click on the links below to read what the other authors in the hop had to say about rule breaking. Don’t forget to drop your email in the box on the top right and have this hop delivered to your inbox weekly. See you next time!













